Choosing the Right Roofing Material for Your Home

Aerial view of a residential neighbourhood along the waterfront in Armstrong, BC

Your Home’s First Line of Defense

Your roof is more than just the cherry on top of your home. It protects everything underneath it! From the structure itself to your comfort, energy efficiency, and day-to-day peace of mind…through snow, heat, rain, and sun…the roof never complains.

For homeowners in Armstrong and across the BC Interior, choosing roofing material for home projects is a decision that deserves careful thought. It’s not just a finishing choice; it’s a long-term investment. Safety, curb appeal, property value…it all adds up. And when you’re making a decision this important, it helps to have a trusted local team in your corner.

Shepherd’s Hardware is a family-owned Armstrong business with a 100-year history, and our goal is simple: help homeowners make smart, confident choices with practical advice and quality products. 

In this guide, we’ll walk through…

  • the key factors to consider
  • a comparison of popular roofing material 
  • common mistakes to avoid so you can choose the right roof for your home

Key Factors to Consider Before You Choose

Before comparing materials, it helps to know what you’re actually looking  for. The best roof for one home may be the wrong fit for another, especially in a climate like we have here in British Columbia.

Budget (Upfront vs. Lifetime Cost)

The sticker price matters, but it’s only part of the picture. A lower-cost roof may need repairs sooner or require replacement earlier, while a higher upfront investment can sometimes reduce long-term costs by way of durability, lower maintenance, or better energy performance.

Climate & Weather Resistance

Armstrong-area homes need roofing that can handle real seasonal extremes: 

  • Heavy snow loads
  • Summer heat
  • Strong UV exposure
  • Even wildfire risk should be considered 

Material performance in its ability to shed snow, reflect heat, and resist fire should be part of the decision.

Durability & Lifespan

Roof lifespan should match your plans for the home. If this is your long-term home, investing in a longer-lasting material may make sense; if you plan to move sooner, a reliable mid-range option may be the better financial fit (though, a high-quality roof can drive up the price of your house for selling, as well).

Home Style & Curb Appeal

Your roof is one of the biggest visual features of your home, so it has a major impact on curb appeal. The right material and color can complement your home’s architecture and even support resale value.

Maintenance Requirements

Some roofs are more “set it and forget it,” while others need regular upkeep. Be realistic about whether you want to spend time and money on cleaning, inspections, and maintenance, or if you’d prefer a lower-maintenance option altogether.

Weight & Structural Support

Not every roof structure is built for every material. Heavier roofing products may require structural reinforcement, which can increase project cost and complexity, so this should be checked early in the planning process.

Roofing Materials Head-to-Head: A Comparison for BC Homeowners

Here’s a practical look at three common roofing choices for Armstrong and the BC Interior.

Asphalt Shingles: The Popular All-Rounder

Asphalt shingles are the most common residential roofing material in North America, and for good reason. They’re widely used because they offer a strong balance of affordability, appearance, and performance for many different home styles. They’re a popular all-around choice and relatively easy to repair when individual shingles are damaged.

Pros

  • Cost-effective and budget-friendly
  • Wide variety of colors and styles
  • Good performance in snow and sun
  • Easy to repair

Cons

  • Shorter lifespan (typically 15–30 years) compared to premium options
  • Can be susceptible to wind damage
  • Not as eco-friendly as some alternatives

Best for: Homeowners looking for a reliable, affordable, and versatile roofing option that balances performance and cost.

Metal Roofing: The Durable & Resilient Choice

Metal roofing includes styles like standing seam panels and metal shingles/shakes. It has become increasingly popular in climates with heavy snowfall and wildfire concerns because it’s durable, long-lasting, and highly weather resistant. The one major drawback is that it requires specialized skills for installation.

Pros

  • Extremely durable and long-lasting (commonly 40–70+ years)
  • Excellent at shedding snow and resisting ice dam issues
  • Fire-resistant, a major advantage in wildfire-prone areas
  • Energy-efficient due to solar heat reflection

Cons

  • Higher upfront cost
  • Can be noisy during rain or hail without proper insulation
  • Requires specialized installation

Best for: Homeowners prioritizing longevity, low maintenance, and superior protection against heavy snow and fire.

Cedar Shakes: The Natural & Rustic Option

Cedar shakes offer a natural, textured look that fits beautifully with the character and landscape of the BC Interior. They’re often chosen for their appearance first, but they also come with tradeoffs, especially in maintenance and fire performance if untreated. 

Pros

  • Beautiful, natural aesthetic
  • Good natural insulation properties
  • Sustainable and renewable resource

Cons

  • Requires regular maintenance to prevent rot and moss
  • Higher fire risk unless treated
  • More expensive than asphalt shingles

Best for: Homeowners who want a natural, rustic look and are prepared for the maintenance commitment that comes with it.

Comparison Table

Material Est. Lifespan Upfront Cost Maintenance Snow & Ice Fire Resistance
Asphalt Shingles 15–30 Years Low-Moderate Moderate Good Fair
Metal Roofing 40–70+ Years High Low Excellent Excellent
Cedar Shakes 20–30 Years High High Good Poor (unless treated)

Note: Lifespans vary based on product quality, installation quality, and maintenance.


Common Mistakes to Avoid

1) Focusing Only on Price

It’s easy to compare quotes and choose the cheapest option, but that can backfire if the roof needs more repairs or replacement sooner than expected. A better approach is to compare lifetime value (durability, maintenance, and expected lifespan) not just upfront cost.

2) Ignoring Maintenance

Some materials need more ongoing care than others. If you choose a high-maintenance roof for the look, make sure you’re also prepared for the upkeep, or the roof may not perform the way you expect over time.

3) Forgetting Local Climate

A roofing material that performs well in another region may not be the best fit for Armstrong. Snow load, freeze-thaw cycles, summer heat, UV exposure, and wildfire concerns should all shape your decision.

4) Neglecting Professional Advice

Roofing decisions affect structure, budget, and long-term performance. Getting advice from experienced local professionals can help you avoid costly surprises—especially around installation requirements, structural support, and material fit for your home (we can help with that).

There’s no one-size-fits-all answer when it comes to choosing roofing material for home projects. The right choice comes down to balancing your budget, your home’s style, and the level of performance you need or want.

The best material is the one that fits your priorities and your home.

If you’re weighing your options, Shepherd’s Hardware is here to help. With 100 years of local history in Armstrong, their team understands what BC Interior homes need and can help guide you toward a roofing decision you can feel good about for years to come!

Stop by for a visit or give us a call today: 1 (250) 546-3002

See More Posts of the Same Category

Aerial view of a residential neighbourhood along the waterfront in Armstrong, BC
Shepherd's Hardware
/
Feb 27, 2026
Seasonal

Choosing the Right Roofing Material for Your Home

Not all roofing materials are built for BC Interior weather. Compare asphalt shingles, metal roofing, and cedar shakes — and learn what to consider before you choose.

Read More
Shepherd's Hardware
/
Aug 5, 2025
Seasonal

Seasonal Home Maintenance Checklists: Your Year-Round Guide

With unexpected weather thrown into the picture, you just never know how long something is going to last. This is what makes seasonal home maintenance so important.

Read More
Shepherd's Hardware
/
Jul 3, 2025
Seasonal

Energy-Efficient Landscaping: Design Your Own Low-Water Garden

Efficiency, sustainability, and resilience—contemporary landscaping isn’t just about looks. There’s so much more to consider in modern times. Learn More.

Read More

Do you need help finding something?

Need a specific product? Speak to an expert today. Our team is here to help.